One Solved and One Unsolved Problem for Conceptual Atomism
نویسنده
چکیده
In this talk I consider two problems for conceptual atomism. Conceptual atomism can be defended against the criticism that it seems to contend that all concepts are simply innate (even technical concepts to pre-technological humanoids) by specifying the innateness thesis as one of mechanisms of hooking up mental representations (concepts as language of thought types) to properties in the world (§1). This theory faces a problem with non-referring expressions/concepts, it seems. Conceptual atomism can, however, deal with non-referring expressions/concepts (§2). Hooking up concepts with properties raises, further on, broader metaphysical problems of making concepts correspond to (natural) properties. These questions are much harder to answer (§3).
منابع مشابه
Solved and unsolved problems in generalized notions of Connes amenability
We survey the recent investigations on (bounded, sequential) approximate Connes amenability and pseudo-Connes amenability for dual Banach algebras. We will discuss the core problems concerning these notions and address the signicance of any solutions to them to the development of the eld.
متن کاملConverging on a New Role for Analogy in Problem Solving and Retrieval
A novel approach to generating retrieval and transfer of structured knowledge is presented. We investigate the effect of comparing two analogous unsolved problems at test as opposed to comparing two solved analogous stories during initial study. We found that both procedures facilitate transfer relative to a standard baseline group studying one solved story and then attempting to solve a new an...
متن کاملCausatives and the empty lexicon: A minimalist perspective
What is the constitution of the meaning of morphemes (lexical concepts)? According to most theories, such meanings have a molecular or holistic internal structure: prototypes, exemplars, semantic networks, complex schemata, scripts, and even classical definitions. Recently, however, contrary opinions have arisen in cognitive science suggesting that lexical concepts are not semantically structur...
متن کاملThe Psychological Implausibility of Naturalized Content
Conceptual Atomism (CA) is the view that psychological concepts are atoms (no internal structure, no necessary relations to other concepts). CA is a psychological/semantic theory. I show that CA has become mixed up with a separate, meta-semantic project that seeks to naturalize content, and that this Naturalized Conceptual Atomism has ended up in the self-defeating position of positing non-atom...
متن کاملMemory for impasses during problem solving.
Three experiments were conducted to investigate the relative memorability of solved versus unsolved problems in long-term memory. In each experiment, subjects worked on a set of potentially solvable word problems, with the time spent on each problem held constant. Problem memorability was then measured with a free-recall task. In Experiment 1, in which a majority of problems were solved, unsolv...
متن کامل